Odorizzi Gets No Local Love in Rookie of the Year Voting
Tampa Bay Rays rookie pitcher Jake Odorizzi deserved better…..He truly did.
I will never be a voting member of the Baseball Writers of America Association (BBWAA), and I never will be. I’m a blogger of an independent blog that is featured upon a MLB owned and supervised blogging community.
The closest I will ever get to being a voting member concerning anything M L B-related will be the online voting process of the GIBBY’s or the internet and in-stadium ballot process for the All-Star Game participants every summer.
Some of you no doubt will brand me a “homer” for the critical commentary I am about to unfold. But I find it personally a bit upsetting and inexcusable for a local media member of our Tampa Bay Rays to not even give one of our own solid rookies at least a solo 3rd place or 1 vote for the 2014 Rookie of the Year award.
He was the only person among the voting panel for the 2014 Jackie Robinson American League Rookie of the Year Award to tip his cap to Odorizzi’s efforts this past season. To make this even more special for Odorizzi is that fact Antonen is a part of the Baltimore Orioles voting bloc and did not have to show any sort of acknowledgment to Odorizzi.
That is a man who voted with clarity and no biased integrity (in my opinion).
I have a mountain of respect for Antonen now, but lost what little I had for Joe Smith of the Tampa Bay Times, and that is my “Two Cent’s” worth of commentary. And believe me, Smith will not lose a single ounce of sleep worried about some blogger calling him out for his ROY voting.
I can understand Smith’s votes for 1st (Jose Abreu/Chicago White Sox) and 2nd (Matt Shoemaker/ Los Angeles Angels), but I am calling bull hockey sticks on his 3rd vote which went to New York Yankee hurler Dellin Betances.
Sure Betances had no chance of winning with Abreu’s garnering all 30 1st Place votes or 150 points, but you would have thought a writer, who is based in the Tampa Bay market would somehow vote for their local guy as a sign of respect for a job well done.
Instead, Smith’s 3rd selection went to a guy who possibly played in Tampa no more than 2-3 seasons ago as a member of the Florida State League (high Class-A) Tampa Yankees. I guess NY Yankees star got a cap tilt vote from Smith to show his community support for the farm team.
Maybe it is the possibly outdated thought process of rooting and voting for the home team guy that has me so worked up here. That a local media member of the BBWAA doesn’t vote for a guy on his local baseball team, but for one who plays on our biggest rival.
But Smith was not the only Tampa Bay based sportswriter to include a Yankee and not a Rays with their 3rd place selection. Dick Scanlon of the (Lakeland) Ledger also did not show any Odorizzi love as he voted for Betances Yankee teammate Mashahiro Tanaka who was on the disabled list for an extended period of time in 2014 but did make a few appearances in September.
So that make 2, count ‘em 2 local Tampa Bay writers who showed their 3rd place love for guys wearing pinstripes instead of possibly gaining some integrity points with the Rays fan base by selecting Odorizzi.
Heck, it would have been amazing and great if at least one of them would of casted a vote for Odorizzi.
I know there are tons of Yankee transplants right now who are going to argue with me and spit back their own logical points, but in the end, the local guy got no love from not 1, but 2 local BBWAA writer……Plain and simple.
I mean if you take a gander at the individual voting ballots of the 30 participating voters in the 2014 Jackie Robinson American League Rookie of the Year voting, some did show some love for a home town rookie after voting for Abreu and Shoemaker in the top 2 slots.
Detroit Free Press writer Lynn Henning showed local love to Detroit Tigers 3B Nick Castellanos, and Joel Sherman of the New York Post showed a hometown salute and a 3rd place vote to Yankees pitcher Mashahiro Tanaka.
And I do not have an issue with Takanao Ishii of the Sports Nippon Newspaper selecting Tanaka for his 3rd place choice. It is an honorable show of respect for the Japanese pitcher that one of his countrymen selected him.
In the end, this is my opinion plain and simple and I can rant and rave all night long and into the orange sunrise and this omission of Odorizzi from the local writer’s ballots will not change.
But then again what was I to expect from a group of local media members who didn’t even vote Odorizzi the unanimous 2014 Rays Rookie of the Year.
You deserved better Jake…in my non-voting opinion.